In their heyday, the Ian St James Awards offered the biggest fiction prize in the UK and Ireland. Launched by the thriller writer Ian St James in 1989 to encourage new writers, the awards were open to 5,000-10,000 word short stories by unpublished writers.
In addition to the prize money, Harper Collins published the twelve finalists in an annual anthology.
I submitted several short stories to the awards when I lived in England (as I wrote in my Short Stories profile). The delivery deadline was the end of February to post a typed copy of the entry with a self-addressed envelope for the return of the critique from the first round of judging. January and February are cold and bleak in England, and the daylight hours are short — perfect for writing.
My routine was to flesh out a story outline by mid to late January, type it up by mid-February, and edit and revise furiously before the deadline.
Not that short a short story
I struggled with my first entries. A 5000-10,000 word story is not that short. And this partly explains why I submitted the same story twice.
However, I did rework the second entry, based on the critique of the first and what I had learnt from another twelve months of reading and writing (for instance, I introduced flashbacks). Both were semi-autobiographical pieces about a young man who sets out to find himself through travel but realises he carries a hidden quest within him.
Inspired by a popular Phil Collins song, my third entry was more ambitious. I wrote four vignettes as backgrounds to news items and pulled them together with a fifth story which reflected upon the accounts and tried to make sense of the character’s actions in each.
The fourth and final entry again drew from my life, my travels and my desire to return home to Australia after eight years of living in England. The main character is a family man who has never travelled and is befriended by a new work colleague who has lived overseas for several years and seems to be his antithesis.
The following are the critiques from the first-round judges for each of the short stories I submitted to the Ian St James Awards:
The First One (1992)
Very few stories score all four ticks for plot, pace, dialogue and characterisation. This story is excellent – well-drawn characters, convincing dialogue and face moving plot. Passed forward for next round of judging.
The First One (1993)
You write well and capture the atmosphere of Bangkok effectively. It would be improved if you worked on the plot, which is rather disjointed. I like your use of flashbacks, which reveal much about your central character.
Both Sides of the Story (1994)
A well written, ambitious and impressive piece of writing. The author’s flair for language is considerable, but I think plot-wise this entertaining story exceeds both the limits and the rules of the genre. Thus, I feel this would be better suited for a novel, and as a short story, it isn’t quite self-contained enough.
A Fine Pair (1995)
I enjoyed the main storyline of this; in the end, both protagonists have become convincing and likeable characters. However, this main theme needs to be emphasised a little more – there’s a tendency for other minor plots and characters to compete for attention.
Thanks for the encouragement
None of my short stories was a finalist, let alone a winner. But the professional critiques provided by the judges inspired me to keep writing! And they still motivate me today.
So thanks for the encouragement, Ian St James Awards!
Both Sides of the Story – 2020 Update
Towards the end of 2019, I revisited my 1994 Ian St James Awards entry, Both Sides of the Story, and in 2020, taking on board the judge’s critique, published it as a collection of short stories.
And I wrote a blog post about Reworking Both Sides.
© 2018, 2020 Robert Fairhead
N.B. This blog post is also published on the Tall And True writers’ website.
Welcome to the blog posts and selected writing of a middle-aged dad and dog owner. Robert Fairhead is a writer and editor at the Tall And True writers' website, and he writes and narrates episodes for the Tall And True Short Reads podcast. In addition, his book reviews and other writing have appeared in various print and online media, and he's published three collections of short stories. Please see Robert's profile for full details.